Mythological Fiction
The Song of Achilles
by Madeline Miller
Member reviews
Samuel Ogundipe
Port Harcourt, NG · 2026-05-18
Thoughtful, layered, worth your time
I went in expecting a quiet read and got something far more forceful. It balances big ideas with small, ordinary moments remarkably well. I've already gifted a copy.
Marcus Bellweather Verified member
Madrid, ES · 2026-05-14
Our best discussion this season
It sat on my shelf for a season; I regret the delay. What impressed me most was the restraint: nothing is over-explained. It has earned a permanent shelf spot.
Ingrid Halvorsen Verified member
Utrecht, NL · 2026-05-10
Read it in two sittings
I came in sceptical — the premise sounded familiar — and was won over fast. There's a warmth running underneath even the harder chapters. A strong recommendation from me.
Yusuf Demirtaş Verified member
Durban, ZA · 2026-05-06
Perfect for a book club
A friend from the Late Night Readers group pushed this on me for months. It balances big ideas with small, ordinary moments remarkably well. I'll be rereading this one.
Elias Thornbury
Bergen, NO · 2026-05-02
Honest without being bleak
I went in expecting a quiet read and got something far more forceful. What impressed me most was the restraint: nothing is over-explained. I've already gifted a copy.
Delphine Rousseau Verified member
Ibadan, NG · 2026-04-28
Made our whole circle argue — happily
It sat on my shelf for a season; I regret the delay. There's a warmth running underneath even the harder chapters. It has earned a permanent shelf spot.
🔒 Sign In to rate and review this book
- Rate and review the books you love
- Build your personal bookshelf
- Get personalized recommendations
- Join book clubs and live discussions
- Unlock exclusive author content
Membership is free and takes less than a minute
Reader comments & questions
23 entries · 8 questions from the community
🔒 Sign In to post a comment or question about this book
- Rate and review the books you love
- Build your personal bookshelf
- Get personalized recommendations
- Join book clubs and live discussions
- Unlock exclusive author content
Membership is free and takes less than a minute
Loading the discussion…
- Comment
Hiroshi Nakamura
Osaka, JP
This is a rare book that trusts its reader. Nothing is over-explained and nothing is wasted.
Marcus Bellweather
I did the audiobook and the narration is excellent, though the print edition has a few visual touches worth seeing.
Rosalind Ayers
Agreed on the ending. It's open, but not vague — the author gives you everything you need.
- Question
Lena Fjeldstad
Dublin, IE
Is this appropriate for our younger members, roughly sixteen and up?
Ingrid Halvorsen
I'd say sixteen and up is fine. There's nothing graphic, just some emotionally heavy ground.
- Comment
Kwame Boateng
Istanbul, TR
I underlined more of this than anything else on my shelf this year. Bring sticky notes.
- Comment
Hannah Lindqvist
Chicago, US
This is a rare book that trusts its reader. Nothing is over-explained and nothing is wasted.
- Question
Nikolai Petrov
Cork, IE
Is there enough here for a two-session discussion, or is one meeting plenty?
Naomi Farrell
I did the audiobook and the narration is excellent, though the print edition has a few visual touches worth seeing.
- Comment
Daniel Whitfield
Edinburgh, UK
I underlined more of this than anything else on my shelf this year. Bring sticky notes.
Oluwaseun Adeyemi
I'd say sixteen and up is fine. There's nothing graphic, just some emotionally heavy ground.
Clara Vandermeer
We paired it with a shorter nonfiction title and the contrast made both books better.
- Comment
Rosalind Ayers
Madrid, ES
This is a rare book that trusts its reader. Nothing is over-explained and nothing is wasted.
- Question
Julian Mbeki
Toronto, CA
Which chapter gave your circle the best discussion? I'm building a question sheet.
Rosalind Ayers
Same experience here. The first fifty pages are slow, then it clicks completely.
